In East Boston District Court, Sharnell Donahue, 31, and Diane Tuck, 51, have pleaded not guilty to the Massachusetts criminal charge of armed assault with intent to rob. Donahue also entered not guilty pleas to the charges of assault and battery with a dangerous weapon and armed assault with intent to murder.

Donahue is accused of allegedly stabbing a 44-year-old woman in the chest in Winthrop on the evening of November 11 and conspiring with Tuck and a 15-year-old girl of robbing the victim of drugs. Police were able to apprehend Donahue and Winthrop because of information gathered from witnesses, including the license plate number of a vehicle seen driving away from the stabbing scene. A black ski mask, which Donahue allegedly wore during the alleged assault, was found in the station wagon. Tuck had a knife with her when she was apprehended.

A judge has ordered Donahue and Tuck to stay away from the victim. Bail was set at $50,000 each and upon posting it the women would have to wear a GPS locating device.

Massachusetts Assault and Battery
Assault usually includes a threat of violence, while battery implies the unlawful physical contact of another person without permission granted. No physical harm needs to have occurred for an assault and battery charge to be filed. In some cases, the alleged threat and intended act will suffice.

Common Massachusetts Assault and Battery Charges:
• Indecent assault and battery
• Aggravated assault and battery
• Vehicular assault
• Assault and battery with a deadly weapon
• Assault and battery upon a child
• Assault with intent to kill • Assault with intent to rob or murder
• Assault with intent to commit a felony
• Assault with intent to commit rape
There are serious consequences that come with a conviction for a Boston assault and battery crime.

Everett women face stabbing charges, Boston Herald, November 12, 2010
Two Everett women deny role in stabbing of woman in Winthrop, Boston.com, November 12, 2010

Related Web Resource:
Massachusetts General Laws

The Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology
Continue reading

Nicholas Christian, a 30-year-old Lynn man, was to be arraigned today in Lynn District Court. He is charged with unarmed robbery on a person over 60, aggravated assault on a person over 60, and receiving stolen property under $250. The charges arose from the beating of an 89-year-old woman while a man stole her purse earlier in the week.

Christian has also been charged in connection with the robbery of a 35-year-old woman in the same neighborhood. That incident occurred on November 7. He was arrested yesterday at his home on unrelated warrants.

The defendant is facing serious felony charges for both of his robbery arrests. Often times, the issue in robbery cases will be the identity of the alleged robber. When there are police missteps in finding out the robber’s identity, evidence can be suppressed and charges can even be dismissed.

In addition, Christian will have to address his outstanding warrants. They are not going away, and it is never a good idea to ignore an outstanding warrant.

When someone is charged with a single crime or multiple felonies it is generally in their best interest to hire an experienced criminal defense lawyer to help them in their case. Hiring a top-notch defense attorney can make all the difference in the world. Among many other things, he or she will provide arraignment and bail advocacy, further your interests in plea negotiations, file motions to disallow certain evidence, represent you well at trial, etc.
Continue reading

Many experienced criminal defense attorneys are going to be needed for the 23 alleged heroin dealers arrested in a large raid yesterday. The ongoing joint investigation by federal and Massachusetts law enforcement yielded arrests throughout the Commonwealth, but primarily Brockton.

Naturally, there was an official on hand to accept credit. United States Attorney Carmen M. Ortiz delivered the news that authorities are committed to prosecuting offenders.

“Today’s arrests should be a clear signal to those distributing drugs in our neighborhoods that the federal government is aggressively working with state and local law enforcement to track their movements, find their associates, and close down their operations,” she said.

And why shouldn’t she be taking advantage of the publicity? This ongoing investigation has, in less than one month, yielded the arrests of over 55 for narcotics and firearms in two busts alone!

This time, folks, it looks like they mean it!
Continue reading

The Supreme Judicial Court has ruled that the marijuana, cocaine, and psilocybin mushrooms allegedly discovered in the dorm room of two Boston College students in 2007 cannot be used as evidence in the Massachusetts drug case against them. John Sherman and Daniel Carr face charges of cocaine trafficking, possession with intent to distribute marijuana, and possession with intent to distribute psilocybin mushroom.

The ruling by the state’s highest court is in agreement with a Superior Court judge’s ruling that prosecutors failed to meet their burden of proof that the two students had given their consent to campus police that their room could be searched. The SJC’s decision overturns the ruling by the Massachusetts Appeals Court, which found that police were within their rights when they conducted the search.

According to Superior Court Judge Linda E. Giles, although prosecutors claim that Carr and Sherman gave their verbal consent to the search, officers have since then given conflicting testimony about what was said that night. The SJC has noted that while the two students signed the part of the consent form that acknowledged the waiving of their Miranda Rights, they did not sign the portion of the form that gave their consent to the search. The court said that even if Carr and Sherman had given their consent, there would still be questions regarding whether or not the granting of this permission was voluntary.

Massachusetts Drug Crimes
Massachusetts drug possession with intent to distribute is a very serious criminal charge. The type of drug involved and whether or not you have any prior drug offenses or convictions can determine the seriousness of your sentence if convicted this time.

An experienced Boston drug crimes law firm can defend you against any charges. There may be reasons why the evidence against you should be suppressed or thrown out. For example, you may not have been read your Miranda Rights prior to making any statements or police may not have probable cause to search you.

SJC ruling tosses out evidence in BC students’ drug case, Boston.com, November 18, 2010
Court: BC police didn’t get OK for dorm search, Boston Herald, November 17, 2010

Related Web Resources:
Fact Sheet on Massachusetts Sentencing Laws, FAMM (PDF)

Boston College
Continue reading

A mutilated body was found in an upscale Milton neighborhood on Monday night. Police told the Boston Globe that the mutilation was extensive and gruesome. Residents are shocked that the body was found in their neighborhood, and police are looking into the possibility that the body was dumped there.

The victim was apparently a five-foot-five black man with an athletic build. He has not been identified and his fingerprints don’t match any of those in the state’s criminal record database. He wasn’t wearing a shirt or shoes when his body was found, and he had no wallet on him.

Source: The Boston Globe, Police seek public help in identifying body found in Milton

As the homicide count continues to rise, pressure will mount on law enforcement, especially when horrific crimes start happening in upscale suburbs where people think they are safe. When this kind of pressure mounts, it increases the urgency of investigations and injustice can result.
Continue reading

Benjamin Haskell, a 25-year-old Springfield man, was sentenced to 6 years in a case brought by Massachusetts prosecutors. The sentence is concurrent with his 9-year federal sentence for burning down the Macedonia Church of God in Christ, a mostly-black church, to protest the 2008 election of President Obama.

Haskell pleaded guilty to a 10-count state indictment. The indictment included drug charges and a charge that he set fire to a house in 2003. Superior Court Judge Moriarty called Haskell a “one man crime wave.”

Source: The Boston Globe, Church arsonist pleads guilty in Mass. case

If you have been charged with arson or any crime in Massachusetts, call the criminal defense lawyers of Altman and Altman LLP. Arson can be a felony or a misdemeanor, and the punishments vary. For example, setting fire to a house of worship carries more serious penalties.
Continue reading

There are many types of defense in the criminal justice system, They are the same in Boston as they are anywhere else. “SODDI”, Some Other Dude Did It, is one of the most popular ones. When the Commonwealth’s finger of accusation is pointed at a suspect, said suspect rarely points his or her finger in the same direction. Usually, it is in the direction of somebody else.

We have discussed many times how prosecution witnesses will often make deals with the government to provide testimony (true or not) against a defendant in whom the government has greater interest in prosecuting.

Prosecution witnesses, of course, are not the only ones who are willing to pass the prosecutorial buck in order to avoid a lifetime in involuntary Commonwealth housing. Two stories this week take such strategies to a new level. Allegedly.

Let’s take the case of Mr. Demare Gary, 19, (hereinafter, Daddy Defendant”) , for example. This Roxbury gentleman stands accused of stashing crack cocaine in the shoe of his Three-year-old daughter. While the Commonwealth may insist that he tried to avoid discovery of the drug by planting it on the little girl, his attorney is claiming that he is actually “taking the fall” for someone else.
Continue reading

A man is in critical condition after being shot in the laundry room of his Lowell apartment building. The Middlesex district attorney’s office, the Lowell police and the state police are currently conducting an investigation. No arrests have been made yet.

The victim is being treated at Brigham and Women’s Hospital and his name has not been released. A neighbor who was familiar with the victim told the Globe that he was a nice man. She said that she was home at the time of the shooting but heard no gunshots.

Source: The Boston Globe, Man critical after being shot in laundry room of his Lowell apartment building

Violent crimes like this one require excellent legal representation. They are some of the most serious crimes possible, and they will be prosecuted aggressively. If you have been charged or think that you might be under investigation for a felony or violent crime, call the criminal defense lawyers at Altman & Altman LLP.
Continue reading

After a week nursing an eye issue, I am back to my Boston Criminal Law Blog…although it may take another week or two to go daily. I plan to blog Monday, Wednesday and Friday this week. Hopefully, the other “mini-blogs” are keeping you informed, if not entertained, in the meantime. However, in my absence, I see (to the extent that my temporary eye patch will allow) that not very much has changed. College campuses are still the scenes of crime, shootings continue and police officers continue to assault and be assaulted.

Let’s take Cambridge’s Harvard University for example.

Kai Robert Kruger, 21 (hereinafter, the “Defendant”) ran into a bit of trouble on Harvard’s campus this weekend. According to authorities, he was arrested after firing a gun at a police officer and attempting to rob three Harvard University freshmen at gunpoint.

Apparently, the Defendant had stolen the students’ wallets, credit cards and cell phones before the officer’s arrival.

But then, his luck began to turn.
Continue reading

Someone looted money from collection boxes and smashed a stained glass window at Roxbury’s Mission Church this weekend. Church personnel reported the theft on Sunday morning. Police told the Boston Globe that between $200 and $300 could have been in the collection boxes.

The church, formally named Basilica of Our Lady of Perpetual Help, is well-known for being the site of the late Senator Edward Kennedy’s funeral. The stained glass window that was smashed was estimated to be more than 100 years old.

Police are investigating the crime.

Source: The Boston Globe, Thieves loot poor boxes at Roxbury’s Mission Church

If you have been charged or think that you are being investigated for a theft crime in Massachusetts, it is important to contact a criminal defense lawyer. There is a wide range of potential punishments for Massachusetts theft crimes, and the penalties can be very serious.
Continue reading

Contact Information